Kalico Kitchen works to bring your style and great taste together in a cake perfect for your celebration
Our cakes are baked fresh for each order, filled with butter cream, and have a moist texture and density similar to a pound cake. Each cake cuts cleanly so that you are not serving your guests a plate of crumbs, but a beautiful piece of cake!

Our Cake Flavors

Wedding Cakes- wedding cake table, 2 tier, buttercream, blue polka dots- 2Basic Flavors (included in base price)

  • Butter Vanilla (most popular flavor)
  • Butter Almond
  • Butter Rum
  • Crème Bouquet (light butter-citrus flavor)
  • Chocolate Fudge
  • Chocolate Almond
  • Vanilla Cinnamon

Specialty Flavors (adds 10% to base price)

  • Sugar and Spice (a blend of traditional apple pie spices with vanilla and almond flavorings)
  • Strawberry
  • Princess (a nutty flavor with undertones of citrus and vanilla)
  • Lemon
  • Buttery Sweet (a rich creamy butter taste, combined with a hint of citrus and vanilla)
  • Chocolate Marble

Wedding Cake Fillings (currently not available for party cakes)

  • Raspberry Cream
  • Strawberry Cream
  • Lemon Curd
  • Bavarian Cream
  • Coconut
  • Peanut Butter
  • Cookies & Cream

Cake Gallery

Wedding Cake Pricing

We offer 3 different pricing categories based on decoration details and icing choice (butter cream or fondant). Prices begin at $3.50 per serving for round butter cream cakes. All of our wedding cakes start at a minimum of 100 servings.

We offer a 10% discount on the base price of our wedding cakes for brides that book at the initial consultation/cake tasting.

There is no additional fee for delivery to venues that are within 10 miles of our location.

tasting fee of $25 will be collected when setting your design appointment. This fee will be applied towards the purchase of your cake.

Design Appointments Check our Availability


Party Cakes

Our single, non-tiered cakes start at $55, and are priced according to three things:

  • Number of servings needed
  • Decorations – multiple colors, fondant details and labor intensive designs will affect the art fees
  • Flavor – specialty flavors listed above add 10% to the base price of the cake

2-Tiered party cakes for 40 or 70 servings are priced at $3.75 a serving. Additional fees may apply for labor intensive designs and delivery.

Check Our Availability


Cake to Go

Our collection of cakes that can be ordered on short notice and/or when our schedule is otherwise full. All Cake to Go cakes are 8 inch round cakes that serve 20 guests. We bake a few extra cakes each week for last-minute orders, and are available on a first come, fist served basis. Prices start at $55

Ordering a Cake to Go is easy:

First, choose the design that best fits your celebration from the Cake to Go gallery

Second, make any color changes to the design that are available.

Third, pick your flavor of Butter Vanilla or Chocolate Fudge.

Fourth, call to pre pay in full, and you’ve got a cake to go! Pricing for these cakes are $50 each.

Cake to Go Gallery